Money Management

Reusable K-Cup: Is It Worth It for Your Keurig?

I drink coffee almost every day. It can be an expensive habit. If you own a Keurig, a single-cup coffee maker, then you know how pricey it can be for just one cup of coffee.

I was at a Starbucks yesterday, and a 12-pack of Pikes Place K-cups was $12.29. That comes out to about $1 per cup of coffee.

You can buy other brands of K-cups that are cheaper. However, one cup of coffee generally comes to .50 cents or more. But can you save more with a refillable K Cup?

Does The Reusable K-Cup Save Money?

In order to save money with my Keurig, I use the Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Filter. This saves me hundreds of dollars per year. All I have to do is buy coffee that is ground and fill up my reusable cup.

Yesterday I decided to get a 12 oz bag of Starbucks Pikes Place ground coffee. They ground the coffee right in front of me. The bag of coffee cost $12.79 at Target ($11.97 at Walmart). They’ll grind it for free.

Then I went home and started measuring. I figured out that it only takes 1/8 of a cup of ground coffee to fill it up. I was able to get 15 scoops of coffee from each 1/4 lb — so a 12 oz bag gives about 45 fills. That means that I could have 45 cups of (10 oz) coffee for a total of $12.79! Plus I get to enjoy it without being rushed.

You have to admit, that’s much cheaper than buying the pre-made singles. And honestly, it didn’t take long at all to fill it myself. It literally took a second. So it’s not like you’re wasting time by using the reusable K-cup.

It’s really easy to use the Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Filter.

Bonus: You’re doing something good for the environment too. K-Cup pods have been recyclable (polypropylene) since 2020, but they are seldom recycled in practice, so a reusable cup still cuts waste — and cost.

What to Look for in a Reusable Filter

Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Filter

Here is what to look for in a reusable filter. Look for BPA-free material and a fine mesh filter that is dishwasher safe. Just toss it in the place where you put silverware, and if there’s a cover to hold in light items, all the better.

Buy the filter made for your brewer; Keurig’s Universal is the manufacturer-approved option for current home brewers. Any refillable cup works the same way, including an Ekobrew you already own.

Let’s Compare Some of Our Single Cup of Coffee Options

  • One cup from Starbucks – Tall coffee (12 oz) is $2.95
  • 12 pack of K-Cups for $12.29 – This is about $1 per cup
  • 48 pack of Green Mountain Coffee for $27.20 on Amazon – Comes out to about 57 cents per pod
  • Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Filter – Roughly 30 cents per cup. A stronger dose runs about 40 cents per cup.

Clearly, the My K-Cup is the most frugal choice. If you’re like me, you’ll find it tough to spend $1 or more per cup after looking at these prices. And the savings can really add up over time. Pods overall run from about 34 cents to over $1.40 each, median about 63 cents.

The Long-Term Savings

So you’re saving about $2.65 per cup with the My K-Cup. You might think that $2.65 isn’t a lot of cash.

But it is amazing how much pennies add up over time. Here’s an example. Let’s say I bought a tall coffee from Starbucks every day of the week. It would end up costing me about $1,077 per year.

Conversely, let’s say I have one cup of coffee using the Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Filter. It would only cost me about $110 for a year’s worth of coffee! That’s a savings of about $950 before the one-time cost of the filter, roughly $15. Compared with pods, you’d save about $260 a year versus $1-per-cup branded pods and about $100 a year versus 57-cent bulk pods.

That might not seem like a lot of money savings. However, if you use a Challenge Everything Budget, you can save on more expenses. The coffee savings combined with other savings will add up big time.

And just think about what you could do with an extra $950 a year. Here are some ideas. You could:

  • Make a principal payment on your mortgage
  • Go on a three-day vacation
  • Pay down your consumer debt

Why not do something different with your coffee and save some cash? Especially when there’s a cheaper option that’ll still get you great coffee.

I understand that not everyone buys coffee at Starbucks every day. However, some people do. And even if you don’t, you’re still saving money with the My K-Cup.

This example helps to show how great the savings is to have a reusable K-cup for the Keurig versus buying a cup from a store.

If you want to start saving big with the refillable My K-Cup, here are some tips. These tips will help you save money without giving up coffee.

What to Keep in Mind When Grinding the Coffee

When you go to have the coffee ground, remember to specify the type of grind. The grind makes a difference in the taste of the coffee. There are essentially two ways to grind:

A Fine Grind – The finer you grind the coffee, the slower the water will pass through the refillable cup. This is great if you like your coffee to have a bold taste. However, you do not want a grind that is too fine.  This could cause trouble with your Keurig. Too fine a grind could cause the Keurig to back up. If this happens, you may get some overflow.

A Coarse Grind – With a coarser grind, water will pass through the refillable cup faster. Because of this, the coffee will not be as strong. Do you like a milder cup of coffee? If so, a coarser grind would be your best option.

Summary

So if you’re a big coffee drinker, you may want to try the Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Filter. Why not save some money on your coffee habit? Start using a reusable K-cup instead.

Using a reusable K-cup allows you to save big money on your coffee habit. Enjoy your coffee habit without worrying about the expense. Switch to a reusable K-cup and skip the coffee shop. Doing so will save you time as well.

No more stopping at the coffee shop drive-thru. Or standing in line at the coffee shop near work. Grab a cup from your Keurig as you run out the door instead.