12 Best Places to Sell Coins Online For The Most Money

Whether you have a single gold piece or a treasure trove of coins, you might decide to make money by selling your coins. If so, you’ll want to find the best places to sell coins online.

The top websites will help you get the best price for your coins while minimizing your fees. They will also connect you with the right buyers.

Here are the best places that make it easy to sell coins online while earning the greatest profit.

Table of Contents

Where to Sell Coins Online

You may have inherited several coins or built your collection from the ground up.

No matter where your coin collection came from, you’ll want to get the best value with the least amount of hassle. Here are the top places to consider if you want to sell your coins online.

1. APMEX

APMEX is one of the country’s largest buyers of coins, currency, and bullion. Since its launch, the site has bought over $1 billion worth of products. With that, this company has a strong reputation for honoring its deals.

The process starts by calling APMEX to describe what you want to sell. If necessary, the team will assist you in identifying the products. You can also submit a form online with the details about your coins.

Once the team understands your coins, they will provide you with a quote that you can lock in over the phone. Additionally, you must have at least $1,000 in coins to sell.

For more information, check out our full APMEX review.

2. The Alloy Market

Are you looking to monetize your coin collection? The Alloy Market offers a seamless solution for selling your coins with confidence.

To get started, visit their website and request a complimentary appraisal kit. Once it arrives, carefully package your coins and utilize the provided prepaid shipping label to send them back securely. Experienced numismatists will evaluate your coins and present you with a competitive offer. Should you accept, expect swift payment within 24 hours.

With The Alloy Market’s commitment to transparency and efficiency, parting ways with your coins becomes a stress-free way to cash in your coins.

3. Cash For Gold USA

Places like Cash For Gold USA are excellent options for selling coins. You can sell your jewelry, valuables, and coins there.

Expert appraisers will evaluate your coins and offer you a fair valuation. If you accept, you’ll receive payment within 24 hours. It’s that simple!

With Cash for Gold USA’s trusted service and quick turnaround, selling your coins has never been easier. Say goodbye to unused coins gathering dust and hello to extra cash in your pocket.

4. Coinappraiser.com

Coinappraiser.com offers a free coin value guide with the option to sell your coins to them. The site’s goal seems to be to help you determine the value of your coins. You can even work with a coin expert to figure out the details.

In addition to this service, Coinappriaser.com also buys coins. The process starts with a call, email, or text to determine the coin’s value. From there, Coinappraiser.com may make you an offer.

However, they might also point you toward another buyer to help you secure the biggest profit. If you make a deal, how the transaction will be handled is unclear. With that in mind, you should proceed carefully when considering selling your coins here.

5. CoinsOnline.com

Coinsonline.com, also known as American Coin and Collectables, makes it easy to sell your coins, currency, gold, silver, and diamonds.

They offer information and pricing for specific coin types, such as silver dimes, quarters, and half dollars, as well as mint sets, silver dollars, and more.

If you have coins graded by a third-party coin grading service, including PCGS, NGC, or ANACS, they may make you a good offer. They are also strong buyers of all forms of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium bullion.

6. Coin World Marketplace

Coin World offers a marketplace for coin buyers and sellers to meet in a single spot. It has built a good reputation that both buyers and sellers trust.

You can create a listing as a seller by describing your coin, adding pictures, and paying a listing fee. The listing fee is 2.50% of the list price for private listing ads, with a minimum charge of $5 and a maximum charge of $299.

They also have packages if you have hundreds of coins to sell:

coin world marketplace - seller packages

Luckily, there is a caveat. If the item doesn’t sell within 12 months, Coin World will reimburse the fee so you don’t lose money.

Purchases are made through an escrow service. With that, you won’t receive the funds until the buyer possesses the coins.

7. eBay

eBay has millions of users who check out its listings. Of course, not all eBay users are collecting coins. Since thousands of other products are available, it can be difficult for coin buyers to find your listing.

However, when a potential buyer does find your listing, you will have more control over the price point.

Keep in mind that you’ll need to factor in selling fees when calculating the cost. Currently, eBay charges between $0.25 and $2.00 to list an item. Plus, you’ll have to pay a 12.35% + $0.30 fee when the coin sells.

If you are comfortable creating listings and covering the associated fees, then eBay could be a great option for making money by selling your coins.

8. Great Collections

Great Collections offers sellers the opportunity to sell their coins at auction. As a seller, you’ll send your items to Great Collections. After Great Collections receives your coins, the company will auction off the items.

According to the site, the company conducts an extensive marketing strategy for these auctions. This means your coins will be seen by many prospective buyers.

When you send in coins, there is no minimum consignment amount. You’ll have to pay 5% for coins and banknotes that sell for under $1,000. You won’t have to pay any fee if the coins or banknotes sell for over $1,000.

There are some instant cash advances available. However, in most cases, you’ll only receive payment after the item has sold.

9. Heritage Auctions

Heritage Auctions is a specialty auction house. With decades of experience selling coins, you’ll likely find success with this option. Through Heritage Auctions, you can sell your coins online outright or go the consignment route. If you sell outright, you will send pictures, and they will determine a price.

If you consign your coins, you’ll need to ship them to the company for auction. With the consignment option, you are trusting Heritage Auctions to get the best price for your coins before you are paid for them.

When your coins sell, you’ll pay a 10% fee to Heritage Auctions. Unfortunately, you won’t receive your settlement check until 45 days after the auction closes.

10. Modern Coin Mart

Modern Coin Mart is a business set up like an online pawn shop. The process starts when you send in your coins. After assessing the value, Modern Coin Mart will send out your payment.

Once Modern Coin Mart owns your coins, the business will resell the items at a profit. You won’t have a chance to negotiate the value of your coin collection until after Modern Coin Mart has your coins in hand.

As a result, it might be risky to put your trust in the fact that Modern Coin Mart has your best interests at heart. After all, the website has to worry about its profits.

11. Stacks & Bowers

Another place to sell coins is through Stacks & Bowers, America’s oldest coin auction house. Stacks & Bowers is renowned among coin collectors as a premier destination for buying and selling coins.

The large, built-in number of buyers bodes well for sellers. Regardless of the item, you can sell it directly to Stacks & Bowers or consign it for auction. If you sell directly, the process starts with a phone call or email. The company may send an appraiser to your home, depending on the situation.

The auction house is known for world record prices. That said, you’ll still have to part with your coins before you receive the payment. If the coin sells, you will receive your funds 45 days after the auction closes.

12. JM Bullion

As you might have guessed, JM Bullion specializes in buying gold and silver bullion. The process is fast and painless. It begins by selecting the products you want to sell online. If you’re satisfied with the price, you can secure it.

After that, you can ship the products to JM Bullion. Once the package is received and inspected, you will receive your payment. If you prefer to get a quote from a representative, that is also an option.

The downside is that you have to wait until after you send the bullion to receive payment. With that, you must trust that the inspection goes well and that JM Bullion can honor their price.

FAQs About Selling Coins

Here are some of the most common questions when selling coins online.

What is the best way to sell coins in bulk?

eBay is the best place to sell many coins in one transaction. Their platform enables you to sell coins in bulk, allowing you to list an entire collection in one transaction.

How do you ensure that the buyer is legitimate?

Many marketplaces have a rating system, allowing you to see how other sellers have rated the buyer. Be sure to review the recent history to assess the current reputation of a prospective buyer.

Summary

If you are ready to sell coins online to make money, you’ll find many places that are looking to buy. You can list the items individually on a marketplace, sell directly to a buyer, or use a consignment auction. Ultimately, the best way to sell your coins will depend on your unique situation.

You may not have the time to manage a marketplace listing, so creating a consignment auction or selling directly to an online shop is a good alternative. If you have the time to manage your listing, a marketplace can increase your profits. Before selling your coins, take some time to determine which option is best for you.

Recommended Reading