10 Places to Sell Beanie Babies That Are in Your Closet

If you collected beanie babies back when they were a hot commodity and are ready to turn them into cash, you are in luck. We’ve found the best places to sell Beanie Babies.

Table of contents

Where to Sell Beanie Babies Online

There are many places to sell Beanie Babies for top dollar. The best place to sell them will vary depending on the timing and demand.

1. eBay

eBay is one of the best places to sell Beanie Babies because you can appeal to a niche audience using the right keywords.

The platform is easy to use and has a high Apple App Store rating. That said, they charge listing and final value fees. Keep that in mind when you list your products.

You can sell items on eBay at a fixed price or create an auction by setting the minimum bid. You can even set a reserve price to make a certain amount before accepting a sale.

The site has the largest audience out of all the options on this list, so you’ll appeal to people worldwide. However, you should determine where you’ll ship to before creating your listing.

2. Bonanza

Bonanza is an online marketplace with a high Apple App Store rating. It lets you sell almost anything, including Beanie Babies.

The site charges lower fees than other online options, like eBay. For example, it charges $0.25 for each item you sell and a 3.5% final value fee.

Plus, you can use the same listings you used on other platforms, like eBay or Amazon, and integrate them into the Bonanza platform.

Keep in mind that you’re responsible for shipping the items to the buyer, so include that cost in your prices to ensure you don’t lose money.

3. Craigslist

If you prefer to sell directly to buyers instead of using a middleman and want to keep it local, consider selling on Craigslist. The platform has a high score on the Apple App Store.

It’s free to list your Beanie Babies for sale on Craigslist, but you must also handle any questions, negotiations, and payments. It’s a good idea to have a way to vet buyers to ensure they are interested and will pay.

If you offer local pickup, consider doing it at a public place, like the local police station or another popular area. This can ensure your safety.

Selling Beanie Babies locally may get you the most money because you’ll have a niche audience or people interested in Beanie Babies who might be willing to pay more.

4. Etsy

Most people know Etsy for its crafts, handmade goods, and art. But did you know they have a large audience for collectibles as well?

Opening an Etsy store is easy and free. Like most apps on this list, there are fees, including a listing, transaction, and payment processing fee. Listing an item costs only $0.20, but the transaction and payment processing fees depend on the item’s cost.

When selling on Etsy, you set fixed prices and decide how to ship the items. Buyers can view your items, save them, or ask questions through the platform.

Etsy works best with a large collection because you can fill up your store with them, selling them individually or as a bundle, depending on the demand.

5. OfferUp

OfferUp is another online marketplace that allows people to sell their items, including Beanie Babies.

You can list items for local sale, accept cash payments, and pay no fees. However, service fees might apply if you offer to ship items or take electronic payments.

Fortunately, OfferUp is transparent with its fees, so there aren’t any unpleasant surprises.

All communication goes through the app, so you don’t have to worry about divulging personal information. You can also set up local sales to be picked up in a safe location or offer to ship for non-local buyers.

6. Sell2BBNovelties

Sell2BBNovelties is an online store that buys products from collectors. Beanie Babies are one of the hottest items they’re looking for, so you might make more money selling your collection to them.

They cover the shipping charges if you have over $30 worth of toys to sell. Better yet, they don’t charge selling fees. You can sell your items individually or in bulk. Plus, you don’t have to worry about an auction ending too low, leaving you with less than you wanted for the item.

The Beanie Babies you sell to Sell2BBNovelties might be sold to other collectors (for a profit), wholesalers, or stores looking specifically for the Beanie Babies you have for sale. They may even be donated.

Where to Sell Beanie Babies Locally

7. Collectible Stores

Depending on where you live, a few collectible stores might be interested in buying your Beanie Babies. Like antique stores, it’s best to find collectible stores specializing in toys for the best results.

Consider getting quotes from several stores to see who can give you the best price. Since they operate as the middleman, these stores pay you less than you might get selling your Beanie Babies directly. As a result, you’ll want to choose the store that charges the fewest fees.

Also, ensure you’ll be paid immediately when you sell to collectible stores. Some stores sell items on consignment, so you won’t get paid until the items sell. Depending on the demand for Beanie Babies in your area, this could take months.

8. Antique Stores

Since Beanie Babies were hot in the 90s, some consider them antiques. As a result, you can head to a local antique shop and likely find Beanie Babies for sale. These stores may buy your collection as well.

Your best bet is to find antique stores specializing in vintage toys. To make the most money selling at antique stores, consider selling Beanie Babies in perfect condition with tags attached and no visible damage.

Antique stores are also a good option if you have an extensive collection of Beanie Babies because they can buy items in bulk. However, you’ll want to sell rare Beanie Babies individually to ensure you aren’t shortchanged on their value.

9. Flea Market

If you love talking to people about your collection and don’t mind spending a few days each month at a flea market, you can make good money selling your Beanie Babies there.

Most people who attend flea markets are after antiques and collectibles. Check out the most popular flea markets in your area and choose a time that makes the most sense for the Beanie Babies you have to sell.

While you’ll likely deal with some hagglers or people who offer a lower price than you’re asking, flea markets can still be fun. Not only can you sell your collectibles, but you’ll even meet other collectors.

Another benefit of selling at flea markets is that you don’t have to worry about shipping. That said, you’ll likely pay a fee for the booth.

10. Pawn Shop

Pawn shops sometimes do buy Beanie Babies. However, it’s best to find pawn shops specializing in toys and collectibles. Otherwise, you might not get nearly as much as your collectibles are worth.

It’s best to sell the Beanie Babies that you can’t sell to antique shops or directly to customers to pawn shops instead. This way, you can get higher prices for your more valuable collectibles elsewhere.

Methodology

We analyzed key criteria to determine the best options for evaluating places to sell Beanie Babies and performed in-depth research to identify the top places to make money selling Beanie Babies.

For online options, we included options that meet one or more of these criteria:

Apple App Store rating of 4.0 or higher (if applicable)
Multiple ratings on the Apple App Store
Reputation among industry leaders
Ease of use
Potential for decent payouts

For local options, we focused on the following factors:

Likelihood of purchasing Beanie Babies
Decent potential earnings
Ease of accessibility

We chose this methodology to ensure our due diligence as we determined the best places to sell Beanie Babies.

Tips for Selling Beanie Babies

Beanie Babies are often worth money, but the value can vary. Their condition, demand, and where you sell them will impact how much you’ll make.

Here are tips to help you get the most money for your collection.

Include Photos

Pictures sell collectibles like Beanie Babies much more than descriptions. Buyers want to see the condition of the items you’re selling.

Take photos from different angles and in good lighting when you include photos. Don’t hesitate to include close-ups of the tags or specific features, especially those most sought after on certain Beanie Babies.

The more photos you include, the more likely you will sell the item for what you’re asking, especially if the photos match the listing.

The Condition Matters

Buyers care about how the Beanie Baby looks from the outside. However, they also care about the inside.

Regarding the outside, buyers want Beanie Babies in mint or near-mint condition. Mint condition means perfect. The toy must be in excellent condition with no rips, tears, or stains. It also means the tags should still be attached and in good condition.

Near-mint condition still means the Beanie Baby is in perfect condition, but there might be an issue with the tag. For example, it could be torn or stained, but still attached.

The inside of the Beanie Baby is important as well. While a mint Beanie Baby will likely sell, if it’s made of Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) pellets, you might get more money for it because this form of stuffing is rarer.

Animals stuffed with Polyvinyl Ethylene pellets are more common. Nevertheless, they might still sell for a good value if they’re in mint condition.

Check the tag if you need help determining what your Beanie Babies have inside. It will state the material.

Try a Beanie Baby Facebook Group

Believe it or not, there are many Facebook Groups for Beanie Babies. This is where you’ll find dedicated collectors interested in what you are selling.

You’ll also get tips to help you sell your collection for more. This advice can be helpful if you aren’t sure what a particular Beanie Baby is worth.

Can You Make Money Selling Beanie Babies?

You might make money depending on the Beanie Babies you have to sell and your timing. But, as with any collectible, there’s no guarantee.

Before selling your collection, take the time to research and determine if you have any extremely valuable toys. If you do, sell them individually using the method that will get you the most money.

However, if you don’t have rare or highly sought-after Beanie Babies, you can sell them as a collection to make the most money.

Summary

If you have Beanie Babies you’re ready to part with, you can sell them and get paid today. How much you’ll earn depends on what you have and how you sell them.

Nevertheless, it can be a fun way to declutter and make money.

Recommended Reading